A tough truth that Zohran Mamdani and Nikole Hannah-Jones must reckon with
Mayor Zohran Mamdani has a Nikole Hannah-Jones problem. He has publicly agreed with the New York Times essayist that the New York City Department of Education is “the most segregated school system in the United States of America.” And his schools chancellor, Kamar Samuels, has promised that “integration” of the schools is one of his main goals. But Mamdani and his team have yet to offer a concrete plan to address the troubling inequalities of the school system.
When Hannah-Jones grilled the chancellor about the lack of action last week, Samuels hedged on the integration goal. He said that the administration is fearful of “pushback that will essentially start to end the conversation.” As one reporter noted, “It was a striking acknowledgment that anticipated pushback is influencing the administration’s thinking.”
But pressure is also mounting on the mayor, from both the left and the right, to do something to address the extremes of inequality in the city’s schools. Although Mamdani and Samuels have convened working groups in five districts to begin talking about potential solutions, Hannah-Jones accused Samuels of “just delaying.”
The hard truth that this exchange reveals is this: Forcibly integrating the schools is impossible for the mayor. Every conceivable option would be illegal because the objective is explicitly race-based in a way the Constitution disallows. It could also prove ruinous for New York families because it would lock children into failing schools they don’t want to attend, and it could be politically catastrophic for the mayor because it would alienate a wide swath of his coalition.
Hannah-Jones ignited a nationwide furor in September with her essay “In Fighting for Every Black Child, Did I Betray My Own?” The piece documents what happened when she and her husband sent their daughter to P.S. 307, a struggling public school in Brooklyn that serves primarily low-income minority children. Their goal was to fight against the inequality of the “segregated” system and try to elevate the performance of the school by their active engagement. Instead, they found that discipline was lax, work went ungraded and school staff were largely unresponsive. Their daughter emerged with academic deficits that required intensive remediation.





