Generate Economic Gains for Every New Yorker
Stephen Voss / Redux

Lessons from Amazon HQ2 for New York’s AI economy

Artificial intelligence is forcing us to contend with historic technological change at a pace we have arguably never experienced before. In 2025, AI startups in New York raised $16.7 billion in venture capital, and while more and more jobs are asking for AI skills, the number of entry-level job postings is declining across industries. The AI boom is making its mark on the city, and though we often hear about the radical upside of AI, we have yet to articulate exactly how the economic gains from the technology will benefit more than a select few while the rest of us face massive job losses. But by learning from past failures, New York City can build new, creative policy solutions that maximize the potential benefits of AI while mitigating the predictable harms.

There’s a lesson from the not-too-distant tech past. In 2018, Amazon launched a national effort to determine where its second headquarters would be located, and New York City was a finalist. The proposal promised 25,000 jobs in exchange for roughly $2.8 billion in state and city benefits (or $3.5 billion if 40,000 jobs were created). After a months-long public and political fight over the trade-offs between tax incentives, gentrification, and the yet-unrealized benefit of Amazon’s expansion into Long Island City, in February 2019, Amazon walked away. Importantly, even though HQ2 didn’t work out, Amazon still ended up with a significant footprint in the city. By 2023, the company had created more than 18,000 jobs, working out of several offices, including the Lord & Taylor building it purchased in 2020.

Losing the HQ2 bid didn’t prevent Amazon from establishing itself in the city, but it did remove any leverage that local government had to hold the company accountable to the job growth and job quality metrics outlined in its HQ2 proposal. Amazon ended up choosing Virginia for its second headquarters. Upon investigation, we can see that Amazon’s HQ2 commitment in Virginia has not yet led to all of the expected outcomes. Because the promised job growth and real estate development haven’t happened yet, the county has no requirement to make grant payments until the company delivers. One of the delays left Arlington Community High School without a permanent home, so in partnership with the Arlington School Board, Amazon negotiated a compromise to commit 30,000 square feet of its office space to the school, fund the buildout, and provide the space rent-free. Performance-based incentives have allowed Arlington to hold Amazon accountable, even when the project is not progressing as originally planned, while maintaining a strong partnership that encourages the company to continue to deliver measurable value to the county.

For New York City, the question is not whether Amazon deserved the tax incentives that were offered, but how the City can negotiate economic development packages that track a company’s progress over an extended period of time, with strict enforcement to ensure that there are consequences if companies fail to deliver. With the behemoths of the AI revolution, those kinds of negotiations have yet to occur. The majority of attempts to regulate the industry have focused on safety: the New York City Council held a 10-hour hearing with Meta, OpenAI, Google, and Anthropic to question their safety protocols and introduced 10 bills that include building guardrails around new AI deployments, protecting whistleblowers and individuals harmed by rogue agents, and requiring AI companies to report safety concerns to Cyber Command within the Office of Technology and Innovation. Last year, Governor Hochul signed the RAISE Act, which institutes greater transparency and reporting requirements for AI developers. This is all for the good of New York, but if government's only focus is on safety, we could miss an opportunity to parlay billions of dollars of investment into an economic boon for New York City.

Ensuring New Yorkers actually share in the AI boom will be one of the defining tests for the Mamdani administration. A good first step would be to bring NYCEDC, the City Council, the mayor’s office, the companies, workforce development organizations, and community organizations to the same table to define a set of goals that guide how AI growth supports the city, and to build the infrastructure needed to hold companies accountable to those goals. Mayor Mamdani and NYCEDC have shown an ability and desire to do so through a new partnership with New York University. Under the terms of NYCEDC’s investment in QFab, 15% of the NYU Central Administration’s proceeds resulting from intellectual property developed at the Quantum Fabrication Facility will go to the City. For the first time, the City will receive returns from intellectual property, establishing a vested interest in the success of the project and building a mechanism through which New Yorkers can participate in the unlimited potential of quantum technology. A similar model should be pursued with AI.

One concrete idea would be creating an AI Fund, a mechanism through which AI wealth can be shared with New Yorkers. The JFK Redevelopment Program provides a model an AI Fund could replicate. To ensure Queens residents benefit from the $19 billion redevelopment of JFK Airport, the Port Authority, in partnership with the terminal developers and airlines, funds and administers a Community Development Program. The program supports job and workforce development, education initiatives, and small business growth in connection with the airport.

An AI Fund would serve a similar role as a collaboration between NYCEDC, city government, community and workforce organizations, representatives from the major artificial intelligence companies, and other experts. Like the Port Authority and JFK, NYCEDC would secure cash and equity commitments from AI companies and administer those funds through a Community Advisory Group. Anthropic’s Public Benefit Fund and partnerships that OpenAI and others have made suggest that there is an appetite for social impact, and an AI Fund would broaden the investment options beyond AI adoption.

Amazon’s $3.6 billion investment in affordable housing provides a use case for how such a fund can help a region. Since 2021, it has funded the creation and preservation of tens of thousands of homes across the Puget Sound region; Nashville, Tennessee; and Arlington, Virginia, the home of HQ2. In New York City, could an AI Fund bolster the growing CityFHEPS budget line to prevent more New Yorkers from losing their homes? For the NYC Kids RISE program, might a fund raise the amount deposited into every New York City public school kindergartner’s account to $3,000 (the City Council’s original proposal) from the $1,000 students receive today? And while the AI Jobs Institute, a new facility that plans to train 40,000 New Yorkers by 2032, facilitates training and connections to jobs, can a fund provide security for workers who are displaced by AI and automation?

Critics may warn that any regulation or negotiation with these companies will threaten New York’s competitiveness and push them out of the state, as though it’s a tax on top of what their employees will already pay. But these companies have already committed to New York: Google has more than 14,000 employees in the city, Meta holds 1.2 million square feet of office space, Anthropic took a 16-story building on Hudson Street, and OpenAI is in the historic Puck Building. They are the new titans of industry with the ability to reshape our economy. They are here because they want to grow here, and with the right deal, the companies can help drive the long-term prosperity of the city.

We’re entering a new age of advancement, and the wealth created from it has the potential to exceed anything seen before. The playbook on policy, housing, education, and jobs is changing, and if we don’t want huge swaths of the population to be left behind, we require new ways of thinking about how to structure society such that everyone can benefit from the upside of AI. We need to articulate what that benevolent future should look like. And because the answer is not coming from the federal government or any one corporation, it falls on cities to take care of their residents.


Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Vital City.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.